Skip to content
My Locksmith

Security

Rekey or replace? The honest answer is usually rekey

5 min readLocksmith 365, Peoria AZ

These sound like competing options and mostly are not. For the great majority of situations, rekeying achieves exactly the same security outcome for a fraction of the money.

What rekeying actually is

Inside every pin tumbler lock is a stack of small pins cut to match one specific key. Rekeying replaces those pins with a different combination. The lock stays on the door, the hardware is untouched, and every old key stops working immediately.

A locksmith can usually rekey a cylinder in a few minutes per door, which is why the cost difference is so large: $18 to $45 per cylinder against $75 to $185 plus hardware to replace.

The one thing most people do not ask for

Keyed alike. If your locks share a keyway — and most homes do — they can all be rekeyed to one key. One key for the front, back, garage side door and the gate.

It costs nothing extra at the time of the visit, and it is consistently the thing customers are most pleased about afterwards. It is worth asking for explicitly, because not everyone offers it unprompted.

When replacement genuinely is the answer

Rekeying is not always right. Replace the hardware when the lock body is cracked or corroded through, when the mechanism is so worn that the key has to be jiggled, when parts are no longer manufactured, or when you actually want something different — a higher grade, a smart lock, a lever instead of a knob.

Also replace when the existing locks are genuinely poor. A builder-grade knob lock with no deadbolt is not worth rekeying; it is worth upgrading.

The thing that matters more than either

Most forced entries do not defeat the lock. They split the door jamb around a strike plate held in by three-quarter-inch screws — which is exactly what comes in the box with most deadbolts.

A reinforced strike plate with three-inch screws reaching the stud behind the frame costs around $15 in parts and does more for your security than upgrading from a mid-range deadbolt to a premium one. If you only do one thing, do that.

Questions people ask

Is a rekeyed lock less secure than a new one?

No. It is the same lock with a different pin combination, and old keys stop working either way. Security comes from the grade of the hardware and the strength of the frame, neither of which replacement changes unless you deliberately upgrade.

How long does a whole house take?

A typical three-to-five door home is under an hour. A good locksmith works door by door so the house is never left open.

Can smart locks be rekeyed?

The physical key override on most smart deadbolts is a standard cylinder and can be rekeyed like any other — usually keyed to match your other doors, so the backup key is the same key.

Locked out, or just planning ahead?

Call and you get a real person, a real arrival window, and a price before anyone touches a lock.

Mon–Fri 7am–6pm · evenings & weekends by appointment

Call nowText

Rekey or replace your locks